Ashley Crowder:
Hi, welcome to connected in 3D, real time Solutions and Digital Twins. I’m Ashley Crowder and I am so excited. Today we were here with Paul Doherty, uh, the current founder of digital Group and one of the founding team members of Revit, which really changed the industry with 3D design for the AEC industry. So thank you so much for joining
Paul Doherty:
us. Thank you Ashley, I appreciate this. And hello everybody.
Ashley Crowder:
Yeah. Um, so you know, you’re often described as a pioneer in the built environment and digital transformation. Can you share a bit about your journey into the space and and what really inspired you, um, on this long 3D journey, you know, founding of the digital Group and before that, Revit.
Paul Doherty:
When I was um, uh, in school, I did well. So they gave me a choice in my third year at architectural school to take a semester off and then come back for a semester. So it would elongate my time in school. But what it was doing was that it was inviting me into an internship. That would allow me to cut down the amount of hours I would need before I had to sit for my architectural license. So I said, yeah, you know, I can do that. I was going to school in Manhattan, but I could have gotten a job at probably any of the architectural firms out there, but I’d be doing bathroom details. Who wants to do that? So I had an offer from IBM in Armonk at headquarters to be their global designer for their tradeshow booths going, I could do that. So I had to learn about all these computers, everything from mini mainframes to these two personal computers. Um, and I had to learn everything about them. So computer engineers and systems engineers used to come, uh, and, and, uh, teach me about all these things because I had to learn it in order to showcase it at a trade show. So I learned quickly that, um, the way that hardware and software work was very similar to the way that we turn on buildings. And I also saw that there was this thing called OEM or other equipment manufacturers. And I said, well, okay, so there’s these motherboards, there’s memory, there’s all these things, but IBM doesn’t make them. They just put them together. I’m going, isn’t that a general contractor because general contractor doesn’t own a door company or a window company or a roof company. They other equipment manufacturers supply them and they assemble it. So I’ve had this, this, this itch actually my entire career that started then saying, why can’t a building become a computer if it’s the same thing, why not? This is different components. And what would happen then if those if those components could communicate with us more effectively, more efficiently. So and and you know, ultimately what happens when one building then gets connected to another building. Isn’t that the internet of buildings? So I’ve had this this idea for a long time, and it’s just now starting to come true. So when I came out of school. Um, with with this tech background, I immediately started to look at the existing way of how we build buildings everything from homes, kitchen blowouts to skyscrapers. And what I noticed was that there was not a lot of automation. And I was like, man, with the stuff that I know, we could really make a difference by saving time, saving money, better quality. And that’s been something me pushing a boulder up the hill since 1987. Right? Long time. So yeah. Uh, when I was, uh, also towards the later part of my internship, um, doing the work study, uh, you know, work and go, go back to school and whatnot, um, I decided that I wanted to take had and I took a course at the Parsons School in, uh, in midtown Manhattan, and it screwed up my Saturdays for about a year. But what I quickly learned was that all CAD was was an electronic pencil to what we were doing. And I always thought that there was there’s got to be a better way. So I would look at other industries and that’s what I still do today, looking at innovations happening in other industries, and see if some of those could be implemented here in the built environment. Again, to create a better built environment, something that is more inspiring, that can be safer, healthier, um, and, and sustainable. So that’s really where the genesis happened, was me working with IBM way back in the day.
Ashley Crowder:
That’s awesome. That’s awesome. And yeah, I mean, CAD, CAD was the first major step. I mean, it was crazy that people would be like hand drafting entire buildings with a pencil on a piece of papers and saying to me, um, but that’s where we were. And then CAD was like the computer aided design version, still 2D. And then Revit was really one of those first to to bring it to, to 3D, which, which that jump is just incredible of how much more information you can, you can embed and understand and share. um, but but to your point, I mean, the, the construction industry is traditionally resistant to change. Um, you know, but but you’ve really been leading efforts to digitize and innovate, so, you know. Explain like how you saw that adoption of of Revit and 3D design and, you know, what are some of the biggest hurdles and opportunities you see for for digital transformation in the field?
Paul Doherty:
Well, yeah. Well we still have a long way to go. Um, and a lot of that has to do with when you put a good technology into practice. It should be transparent to the process. It should be like magic. Well, that’s the way that that should have happened, right? The fact that you have all these consultants for BIM, uh, you know, working and that shows that the technology still is not matured yet. Um, the market’s maturing from the standpoint of we’ve designed building information modeling for. A profession that didn’t exist back in the day. It was never meant to be a design tool. That was one of the functions of it. Excuse my, uh. Sorry. Change your seasons. But. But when we designed it, it was really meant for what is now known as virtual design and construction professionals. But this is an important phrase because I’m seeing design and construction. Right? Virtual design and construction. That means you have to understand how to design, and you also have to know how to construct one of the things that 3D brings. And it’s something that really caught my my eye because back in the mid 90s, there was a big push for browser based technologies. People were looking at AOL and CompuServe and calling that the internet. Right. But it was really about the browsers. And so I decided to write a book about it called Cyber Places. Um, and the book itself is something actually, I actually have a copy, and I didn’t realize it. Oh, wow.
Ashley Crowder:
Nice. The way that that that I wanted this to come around. So. Nice little book, right? Yeah. So this is with, uh, means was the publisher, and this really tried to describe all the different tools that made up the internet back in the day, and how it could practically be used in design, construction, and facility management following the lifecycle of every building. Now what what was really interesting back in the day was that everyone was rushing to say, wow, we could actually have a lot of information on this website and we could manage projects with it. So projects, projects, specific websites were all the rage and people were throwing tens of millions of dollars at these things with startups that only had maybe a PowerPoint, let alone a website. And it was crazy. It was the dotcom craze, right? Well, there was this little company out of Cambridge, Massachusetts that said, we have a a 3D parametric CAD tool, and it’s on the desktop. Has nothing to do with the internet, but could you help us? I’m like, why the hell did I help you? I’m Mr. Internet, I wrote the book on it, right? But they convinced me that this was a different way of communicating, that they could take design intent and communicate more effectively with the constructors. Mike, fad is a very sound strategy. Let’s roll up our sleeves and work. So. It was this little office that on Mass Ave in Cambridge, Massachusetts, up above a Domino’s Pizza, and they were called Charles River software. And it was a very interesting piece of technology because it just wasn’t 3D. It was exactly what you said. It was 3D, but with the potential of having data management behind it. So we renamed it from 3D parametric CAD, because the thing that I loved, because I was a hand drafter back in the day before CAD, right? If there was ever a change, you’d have to go through all the different sheets and make sure that the revisions were done on every sheet, right? With this, I could change it in 3D and everything else just fell into place. I’m like, okay, that’s worth the price of gold right there, right? So we got involved, started to massage it for use in architectural practice. Uh, and then we looked at it from the aspect of how a big firm would use it as opposed to a sole practitioner. So we really went through a good iteration to, to market this thing. Um, and we renamed it Building Information Modeling. Uh, we also renamed Charles River Software to Revit. Uh, and we had about $800,000 worth of sales when Carol Bartz and her team over at Autodesk Motors for $133 million, that was a really, really good day. I said, screw architecture. Awesome.
Paul Doherty:
I’m just going to be there for the tech. Right? But you know, but now because we were designing it for a management purpose, Architects were the lifeblood of Autodesk and they sold it as a design tool. I think we lost a good decade, a good decade trying to push that boulder up the hill because it really was not matched well. Even the algorithms, there were just not 100% there. You know, you get up to a certain amount of data inside of your model and it would freeze. I mean, lots of mistakes with this thing, but it was it was the seed that was planted. To Autodesk Credit, they spent a lot of money uh, redeveloping Revit. Uh, and then people started to see the adoption factor shift from design to people that had to implement mostly subcontractors. Interestingly enough, because the GC, what they would do is they get drawings or in this case a digital model, and they hand it off to the subs because the other ones have to do the work right. So GCS act as like a middleman when it comes to this digital transformation. But an interesting thing happened when we started to see that type of, of of pass, uh, passing of the information. It goes back to exactly what we do in our industry, which is the designers communicate design intent. And in 3D you can communicate better, right? Instead of interpreting in 2D and having to learn all these symbols and whatnot, you could just look at it in 3D. So if you live in 3D, we act in 3D. We should be designing in 3D and constructing from 3D. Actually, I’m still waiting for that to happen. We still go. Yeah, slowly and surely. But you know, what’s interesting is, is the maturation of what I thought was going to happen quickly. Um, people fall back into their comfort zones really quick. And regulatory also has a role here. The majority of people that use Revit, or any type of building information modeling software to create the design in 3D, their deliverables are still two dimensional plans like blueprints. It’s like, why don’t you just stick with AutoCAD? You were better at it. Yeah. Yeah. So I was going to say we I you know I agree that that regulatory piece is important. And I am at least seeing in the industry I mean the one the interoperability of the 3D asset is really important because if you’re trying to share this across organizations, from the architect designer to the GC to to the sub, it needs to be seamless and easier or they will just be like, whatever, just give me the old plan. Um, but at least in the manufacturing space where, you know, we’re working with some, you know, big mining clients and others who design parts that go into these big plants, which is, you know, it’s still the built environment, but more industrial. Um, they’re actually getting contracts that require sharing of the 3D model now, which I thought was very interesting. Um, and, and so at least. the end of that industry is saying, hey, this 3D model to your point, we need it because it makes our lives so much easier and better and reduces rework because it’s so much more clear to the sub of what they’ve got to do. Um, is is important. But for that to happen, uh, you know, interoperability is is key. And so if you’ve got a Revit file but then your sub doesn’t have a license to Revit, you know, what do you do. So curious. You know what what you think interoperability standards need to look like. And and you know how do we make this work for construction and and smart cities.
Yeah. So when you’re talking about manufacturing uh either through, you know, consumer grade products as the output or B to B, that type of thing. Um, the supply chain of that, um, is defined and there are contracts in place and there are schedules and budgets. And it’s, it’s not as chaotic as building a building right where we’re building a building, you can kick a subcontractor off and get another subcontractor in. But is that subcontractor even understanding what they’re contracted to do? Uh, you know, I mean, that happens or, uh, or equals right value engineering where, you know, you have a cola toilet, but this guy found something cheaper at Home Depot, and he substitutes it right now. How does the digital transformation fit into that when you’re talking about human condition? Um, and also then human cognition. Meaning that the majority of people in the construction industry. They learn through repetition and through relationships that either have been inherited. Like, you know, it’s your dad’s, you know, framing company, and you take it over to people that are new to the industry and they come into it, uh, where in certain cases, people need bodies, right, in order to swing hammers and saw and do all this stuff. Unfortunately, the quality level that is all over the place and you can only control so much. So what we decided to do way back in the day, like in the 90s, was why don’t we start to take a look at standardization of process and allow the technology to actually become the solution over time? So I’m very fond of process mapping, meaning how work gets done. I would I would guesstimate that 98 to 99% of all the firms that make up the built environment in our in our country have don’t even know what a process map is, let alone have one. So they only know how work gets done through communication repetition over time, but they don’t process mapping. It’s almost like they instinctively know what to do. They know all the safety factors. They can go through training, they can do all this stuff. But unless you process map it, you should never implement a technology, meaning that you have to know what to automate, where, when and how. And that’s just within your organization. Now, your organization, depending on your role, you’re only on that project for a short amount of time when you’re scheduled, right? Very rare that even an architect that goes right from pre design all the way through facility management. There’s different people even within that architectural firm that won’t be on that project the entire time. Right. So that so that means that tools that can interoperate become vital to successful projects because the handoffs to people, they have to understand what am I inheriting and then what am I leaving behind. So again, getting back to design intent, um, I was working with a group out in San Francisco advising them, uh, on a project for the San Francisco Giants baseball team. And they were moving from Candlestick Park, which was in the suburbs, into downtown San Francisco. And they needed to communicate design intent to get the blessings of the mayor and the city council and whatnot. And they didn’t want to spend money on heavy 3D software to do it. Number one, expensive. Who’s going to do it for me, yada yada, yada. So this group called Planet Nine, uh, they they worked with me and I said, listen, I think we can do it for on a piece of software that’s free. And they’re like, what, these web browsers? I said, let’s take the HTML and let’s go to a friend of mine down in Silicon Valley that was working with this newer type of protocol called VRML Virtual Reality Markup Language. So we did it, um, and uh, it was very successful as free people freaked out because they could see the San Francisco Giants baseball stadium without the use of traditional software. So there’s the screenshot of it. That is a Netscape browser. That’s how old this thing is. And this book was published in 1997. That was 1996. We were doing this. We called it the metaverse. Wow. We’ve been at this a very, very long time. So to your point, that model did not need to have all the information that made it up, like what we do today with building information models. It was meant for a certain audience. So that meant that the 3D geometry needed to have a certain level of detail to make it look like it was real. Right. So that that level of detail meant that it was close to photorealistic, but to others, we didn’t have to have that level of detail. Sometimes people work better off sketches because that’s what they’re used to, right? Like like the visor diagram for, for an electrician. Do they want to see a full blown 3D model? Of course not. But to others you do need that, right? So again, communicating that design intent to your point, you do not need to have those heavy models. But we are looking for solutions that can create roles about what that information needs to be. But that means you you need to have a centralized system, like a digital asset management system to pull from, because that could be could be the single source of truth.
Ashley Crowder:
Yeah. And I mean, that’s exactly you know, what? We’re trying to help people do. You know, they’ve they’ve invested so much in these 3D designs, whether it’s Revit or others. But being able to have that centralized place automate those different levels of detail, to your point, because somebody on a job site just wants to quickly pull something up on their phone to, to see exactly where these, you know, the toilet needs to go and which one it is. Um, but they don’t need the full thing. And so I think, you know, that’s so important. But with that, I agree, you know, web. Is the place to do that. So they, you know, just on your phone, everyone’s got a cell phone, you can pull it up. You don’t necessarily need a huge desktop computer with every CAD license possible. It’s not going to be happening on a jobsite, you know?
Paul Doherty:
And depending on where you are in the United States, which market you’re in, um, this could be a critical mission critical, um, uh, workflow process. And here’s a case in point. So I live in the Sun Belt, I live in Memphis. Everything from Florida up to Memphis going all the way out to California. We have a very large community of Hispanic speakers. So I thought it was always like a very easy thing to do. I would take my Revit model and convert it into Spanish. Translate. How cool. Right? Google translate and I thought that that solved the problem. Um, no. It compounded the problem because the problem with the a lot not not all of that community is that a lot of them are illiterate. They don’t even have to read Spanish. So I converted it for no reason, which is why 3D becomes such a huge, huge deal to communicate design intent. Because I can create now work packages that when those tapers are coming onto my project to tape up the drywall. I know I can show them this is what you do today. You go from this point to this point. Tape. Okay. Yeah, they get it right. So the rework goes down in the field. There’s there’s no miscommunication. And things just get easy. So you’re 100% correct having a device like a phone. Um, originally I thought it was a safety hazard out in the field. Now it’s it’s a it’s it’s as important as the tool that you use for your trade. Yeah.
Ashley Crowder:
No, 100%. I mean, if if, you know, if picture explains a thousand words, a 3D model explains a million and without anything, you know, um, that that’s huge. And so, uh, are there any specific projects, um, you can think of where, you know, but the baseball stadium is, is a great one. But any other ones you want to highlight where you’ve really seen digital twins, you know, reshaping this entire design construct and built environment.
Paul Doherty:
Yeah. And, you know, I think definitions are probably, um, necessary in order to follow the storytelling that needs to happen in our industry. Um, so. Digital twins when they were first starting to define what they are. Unto themselves. I looked at other industries and they were doing a good job of the descriptions. It was literally a mirror image of what’s in reality right now. BIM has always promised that. But I can promise you the majority of BIM is not. Yeah. Um, you know, one thing about hand drafting, uh, which is where I grew up, you know, literally having to roll up my sleeves so I didn’t get, uh, you know, lead on my shirt and all sorts of things that no longer exist. Right. Um, I was in a drafting pool. Meant that was a very large room with drafting tables. And there would always be more experienced designers just walking, passing through. And by happenstance, maybe they they caught something. Maybe your lettering was off that day, or your dimension lines were just a little off and they’d stop and ask a question. Imagine that. Talking with each other, handing down knowledge from one generation to the other that was not meant to be like in a classroom, but just in the just in the flow of work. And they would say, what are you working on over here? But I got this detail. I was like, well, that’s not the way that we do it. This is what we learned. That type of communication now is almost lost when you get involved with the, the, the myopic view of zooming in and zooming out on a computer screen. Right. So this is where, um, you know, we started to take a look at, at the world of 3D and digital twins in a very unique way, where BIM is one communication channel, right? And that’s a very, very heavy model that can be used between architect and engineer, the engineers and the experts and other systems and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. But in order to create the digital version of what will be a building, both interior and exterior, but with digital twins, what we found is that depending on how you want to, you know, work with the information that defines what it is. And let me give you an example. So there is um. There’s this notion that you can take, uh, the building information model. And if you wanted to show the interior, there are tools that you can purchase and use that will give you the ability to create a path so that someone can walk through it. Right? But but that’s staging information. What really was the big breakthrough about a decade ago was the massive use of gaming engines, things like Unity and Unreal and things like that. Now you’re giving the end user the ability to walk through the space of what they want to see. Now things get very interesting. We call that a virtual world, right? Meaning that the digital twin now is your virtual world, your your. You can discover what that design intent is, or you can look around and say, hey, listen, that’s not quite right. This is how we do it. And then communicate that back to the designers so that so that they can make the change. This is where we’re getting into the world of large BIM and tiny BIM, right? Where, you know, there’s a massive amount of information, but maybe just the proper information. So, you know, large BIM, little beam. Uh, and also this idea of moving from digital twins into virtual worlds. Eventually, those virtual worlds, through things like standardization, being able to take objects and be able to share them in in environments that are outside of the authoring tool. That’s a big one, right? Because the authoring tool, they want you to be proprietary, but once you now emancipated, right, and give it the freedom it needs now, all of a sudden we can start to link things together. That is the promise of what the metaverse will be. Is this linking together over time outside of the authoring tools that originally created it?
Ashley Crowder:
Right. And in that real time environment. So unity, unreal game engines, Nvidia’s Omniverse, a lot of people are starting to to use. But having that real time technology. So to your point, someone can can walk through and see it. My mother has redone the kitchen. I don’t know how many times my poor dad, you know, that’s not what I thought it would look like, you know? So, uh, avoiding that type of rework. Um. Is, is is incredible. But that’s really the power of what what real time technology that’s developed in the past ten years has, has enabled. And I know I’m so excited about it. I mean, how do you see the technologies and practices, um, evolving over the next five years? You know, what do you see becoming standards,
Paul Doherty:
things that make money is really where the rubber meets the road, and that’s where massive adoption happens. So let me give you a case in point. So we designed a theme park in Qingdao, China called the Virtual Reality Theme park. Right. Um, and it was meant to be an experiential is an experiential, uh, uh, theme park in that when you designed a traditional theme park, uh, they even designed that being on the line to get into the right as part of the experience. Then you do your 7 or 8 minute ride, and then you come out into a retail establishment. That’s the Disney model to universal model, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah
Ashley Crowder:
works very well. I just wanted to
Paul Doherty:
follow it. Yeah, Imagineering does a great job with, uh, managing people that way. And they actually have, um, an amazing display of data based upon demographics. So let’s say you’re a family of four, traditional family of four, you know, you know, a son and a daughter, uh, at a Cleveland, Ohio down on spring break into Orlando. And you are now standing in line for the avatar piece. It’s about 90 minutes. They can tell that you’re going to make a right hand turn when you get outside of the retail establishment. Mhm. 85% of the time, the other time you may go left. So what they do is that they manage through a lot like on a map, all these dots. And they go through simulations to help understand the flow of people. And also then for security and safety, how do I do that inside of a virtual reality environment? Because I have are people that are looking through, you know, like a phone or a tablet with people that are immersed in goggles. I can’t co-mingle those people because there’s injury and all sorts of things that happen. Plus they’re in a virtual world too. They even need the pavilion. Well, yeah, you do, because you need to sell merchandise and stuff like that. But the bottom line is the space between the buildings now become part of the theater. Right. So we had a really, really rethink and reimagine for safety, security reasons and also for entertainment reasons. How do we start to manage people in a way that provides them the illusion that they’re doing self discovery, yet we’re actually forcing them to make that right hand turn or whatever it is. Right? So then we started to take a look at the 3D geometries in a very unique way. Um, we put it onto a gaming engine, and we released it up on the internet so that Tencent, who was one of our big, uh, tenants, could have a portal to all of their titles, everything from World of Warcraft to, uh, a League of Legends, all these famous games. Except that in China. The phones. Games are the largest in the world, right? So now we had a really rethink. Things to say, right? Um, could we release this and have people pay for download? In other words, let’s make our 3D Revit model on a gaming engine a revenue center. We saved 18% of our construction budget before we opened up the gates, because people paid follow the money paid to be part of that experience. It also doubled down that they wanted to experience it in real life. Because we have a 1 to 1 Fortnite island I want to go see, right. And then of course we sell merch and and all sorts of things and they want to come back. It’s the Disney model, you know, tell them what you’re going to tell them. Tell them what you’ve just told them. And and now it becomes a continuous improvement cycle. That is how I’m seeing 3D and more importantly, the data behind the 3D being a huge driver for growth over the next half a decade, decade, you know, 25 years in the future, because now you’re getting down to touching people’s experiences and their feelings and and how they can be inspired. Right. So I think that, you know, as we move forward, I’m looking at the Web3 technologies being integrated seamlessly into these 3D geometries in order to provide those good storytelling and those good experiences for branding, marketing, all of that type of stuff. So when I hear things like crypto, I immediately go, hmm, that’s interesting. Could we tokenize our models? In our projects and then start that process. That’s going to be a very interesting thing to to keep tabs on. Can we start to take things like smart contracts. Mhm. We out of blockchain and start to create a different relationship between people and between the contractual obligations they have, especially when it’s transparent. My goodness I mean I can’t hide behind a contract or not not not fulfill it. Not anymore.
Ashley Crowder:
So yeah I mean crypto has gotten such a bad rap over the past couple of years, but the technology is really incredible because it is and it is determining the single source of digital truth of this 3D asset and who owns it. And I actually had an interesting, you know, podcast with Albie Gluten, who’s working on digital rights management, uh, using using the, the, you know, blockchain technology to ensure this 3D model is owned by Toyota or this 3D design architectural is owned by, you know, this architect. And so it becomes so much more valuable and clear, um, who owns what and and what is a real design versus a knockoff. And it’s so important. And I know with with the digit group, you’re doing a lot around the designing of, uh, smart cities. And so that, you know, um, insulation in China is super interesting, but but, you know, I’m not sure if you have an example how the 3D visualization and digital twins are really contributing to smarter and more sustainable urban environments as well. I know which a lot of people care about right now.
Paul Doherty:
Yeah. Um, in the Middle East, I can point to a project that a lot of people do know about. Um, 2016. I was brought over by McKinsey company and, um, Boston Consulting, uh, to work with them in Riyadh for a number of months to create a roadmap for the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, uh, to transform itself. Uh, it’s called vision 2030. My chapter. I was responsible for the city of the future, which is now called Neom. So. Yeah. Yeah, that’s my that’s my baby. Not off the line, by the way. I’m not a big fan of the line, but, uh, you know, that’s it. We’ll see how all this works out. But, you know, the idea of smart cities actually came out of the world of 3D. Um. Because of the success we had with Revit. Being sold buzzsaw was another one that we sold to Autodesk and tried Rega that was purchased by IBM, my old alma mater. Um, I had some very good success with that. Uh, created a lot of value, uh, and revenue for the different investors. So I was a little bit of a darling. Still am. Uh, up and down Sandhill Road in Silicon Valley. And they would hold events, these VCs, uh, you know, the sequoia capitals. And back in the day, Silicon Valley Bank, rest in peace and all these different groups. And I got invited, uh, to be part of these little get togethers. Uh, during the one of these get togethers, I was introduced to a gentleman named Remy Arnaud. Remy is one of the rolled up businesses that became Google Earth. It used to be called keyhole, and he was telling me that he wasn’t really happy with with his time at Google, uh, because he felt that Google Earth in particular was kind of dumb. It’s like, you know, he he was the guy that did the tiling was called intrinsic, you know, like you’re you come up from, you know, the space and then you come down to the continent, down to the state, down to your house. Right. Um, he said that took a lot of time because it was all imagery. But then you had to attach data to the imagery in every aspect. Street view, to this day, you know, it’s all just images when they’re just dumb, he said. I really feel that data should drive the geometry. So we created a tool called Orbi, and what Orbi did for us was that it just wasn’t about seeing one project in a proprietary, proprietary piece of software. I could see adjacent properties, I could see entire districts, I can see entire cities. Or in a browser. And it was remarkable what what we did there. So, um, IBM came around again and said, we’d like to purchase this thing from you. And I said, no. And I rolled up my sleeves and I rededicated the digit group to being a real estate development group that had the tool that no one else had, which was Warby. So we got involved with working with, um, uh, large scale projects at the time, uh, China was going through a huge transformation of putting in high speed rail to connect cities. But then once you connected the city, they were digging up these ancient cities and new cities for two reasons. Number one, they had a thing called the Sponge City program that was helping with the flooding that was happening because of the undersized piping that was all throughout all these cities. The second thing was they were they were digging for subways, especially Shanghai and Beijing. Beijing was going for the 2008 Summer Olympics. 2010 was the world, um, the World Expo in Shanghai. So they dug up all this stuff, and they installed all of the subways to help with the high speed rail that connect the cities. And suddenly I had a platform. I could actually show them what to do, how to manage these things in 3D. And that’s where the term smart cities actually came from. It was part of IBM’s Smarter Planet, Smarter Cities Smarter building program. So that’s when yeah, that’s what I wrote this, which was actually how to do Smart Cities. And it was not just on the technology side of things. Technology drove the message, right, but it was to get people to communicate better so that they could actually take control of their own built environment. And that’s the big thing about, you know, smart cities. It’s not so much the innovations and the technology behind it. It’s can you enable its inhabitants to start taking a a better approach to understanding how they live and how they operate? Because, you know, it’s it’s very, um. Jarring when I go to these smart city conferences everywhere and people have all the solutions. I’m like, yeah, but did you actually ask the people that actually live there and work there and visit there?
Ashley Crowder:
Yeah. Are they going to actually enjoying it? Yeah. Are they going to operate in the way you expect
Paul Doherty:
not just to impose your will onto other humans? It’s like, you know, there’s a there’s a term for that. It’s called a dictator, right. I mean that’s not that’s not something that that like, you really want to do. So yeah. Um, in the Middle East, I got very lucky with me. Um, actually worked with, um, leadership in the UAE for Expo 2020. Uh, but here in the States, I have a brand new project, and it’s like, one of the coolest things ever. Uh, it’s in Miami. Uh, and we’re about to announce it publicly. So this is actually the first time others can hear about it, and it’s called the Miami International Maritime Museum. Now there is no maritime museum in Miami, which was staggering, I thought. I mean, they’re all about ships, especially today. The cruise lines and
Ashley Crowder:
everything in the country. Yeah.
Paul Doherty:
So what happened was I got introduced to, uh, a gentleman named Yuri Santana. He’s Brazilian, but comes from a Lebanese heritage. Very unusual, very un. Um, yeah. And he’s an award winning documentary guy. Does documentaries that have impact? He’s very well known in the Imax circles and stuff like that. Uh, so he he’s been working on a documentary on the Amazon, uh, and everything that’s going on with it from its past history to today with the deforestation, how that affects you, blah, blah, blah, how it affects the, the river life, uh, you know, the vegetation, all that’s of inner air, obviously. Right. During his discovery of all this and documenting. Right. Um, on film, uh, they discovered shipwrecks at the mouth of the Amazon River. And what they did was they found some of the wood, they went ahead and they wanted to look at the carbon ization to find out where, where’s the wood from, what type of ships these were. And. It was cedar from Lebanon. Wow. What is that doing there? Right. And the estimated that it’s 3000 year old wood. So he went back to Lebanon, um, and found that there is an area in central Lebanon bleeding into the western part of Syria. That’s one of the largest forests of cedar trees. I never knew this. And then all of a sudden, you take a look at the Lebanese flag and watch right in the middle of it a damn cedar tree. I’m like, wow, how did that happen? Right? So all of a sudden he goes in and he starts to realize that this is from the Phoenician period. Now, the Phoenicians were famous not so much for countries or anything like that, but for for their ports around the Mediterranean. They were traders and long distance traders because they knew how to build boats. They were excellent carpenters and craftsmen. And what did they sell? Wood. That was their main deal for like, like 3000 years ago, right? Their largest port, uh, that they settled into was Carthage from biblical times. Right. Now, what happened was they, uh, through Yuri’s study and his research, they found more shipwrecks in the Canary Islands also around that same time of Phoenician period. Would. So what they theorized was that if they could rebuild the boat done back in the day, just like they did in the Phoenician period, that they could prove that the Arabs, the semantic Arabs, were the first ones to discover the New World, not the Vikings and not Columbus. So so Saudi Aramco heard wind of this and said Arabs discovered the new world. We’ll put some money into that. The Smithsonian Institution then said, we’re going to cover this. And they did it. They built the boat. The only thing they had modern on the boat was an emergency CB radio. Everything else, including the navigation, was done with tools from back in the day, tools that that would allow you to look at the stars and the horizon line and figure out what direction you’re going. Like. They really got into this
Ashley Crowder:
finding. Yeah. What
Paul Doherty:
they did was they they sailed it all the way through to the, to the Dominican Republic, and they wound up in Miami. And so we’re going to be showcasing the Phoenician ship that actually has now an Imax movie, but, you know, filmed about this thing. We’re going to showcase it as a way, not just of showcasing the boat, but all maritime to celebrate that and more importantly, everything about water, the rising sea levels. Why are we going through a period of construction in Miami like it’s never seen before? But they’re building it like it’s 1970, guys, your first four floors are going to be underwater in the next ten years. Why are you building like this? I mean, the insurance companies are going to go crazy, right? So what we’re doing is we’re building underground on the sea. We’re right at the sea level because it’s counterintuitive, because you think you want to go up with stilts. No, no, no, no. You want to go down and embrace the water almost like a big bathtub without the water inside. So we’re doing this whole experience based upon the same technology that the the founders of Imax left Imax. Because they did not. The public utility company IMX now did not want to go to an IMX 2.0. It’s just too expensive to change all their theaters. So they left their baby and they created chasm. Chasm. This is the technology that’s behind the sphere in Las Vegas. Immersive way of really starting to get into, you know, this shading of almost holographic. But you’re sitting in this amazing destination that’s changing rock music. It’s changing, you know, movies.
Ashley Crowder:
Incredible. It’s VR without the headset. The the Dolans are actually one of our largest investors. And so, you know, we’ve I got to see the the testimony sphere like a few years before it opened. It’s
Paul Doherty:
incredible. Well then Tyler in that team, that’s their technology. Now they’re creating their own destinations. There’s one at SoFi Stadium in L.A. Um that’s incredible. That shows like during the World Series, they projected Yankee Stadium inside of this LA based chasm. And it looked like because they actually had the broadcast, the TV broadcast in the cars. And I’m like, why are there so many Dodger fans in Yankee Stadium? It was that convincing. I didn’t know I was like, wow. Yeah. So they just opened up one in Dallas-Fort worth as well as destination places. And the third one, sorry, the fourth one in the United States is going to be in Miami at the Maritime International Miami International Maritime Museum. And what we’re doing is we’re changing the the way that we use museums as a, as an experiential center. But more importantly, all the 3D that we’re doing, we’re going to be taking a page right out of the VR theme park in Qingdao, China. We’re going to be opening up a year before it’s built, and we’re going to have people pay to be inside of these experiences virtually. So that’s one way that we’re going about it. Again, it’s pushing the limits of of virtual worlds. And how can you practically make things happen? Because this is going to be a showcase for for Miami to say the horse has left the barn. You think you’re going to lower the temperature of the Earth. Good luck with that. Climate change is here. Sea levels are going to happen. So let’s start building differently. And here’s a showcase of one example of how. So this immersive way of working also then gets into how this business model works in that when the Miami Dolphins, the heat, the Florida Panthers and, uh, the Florida marlins, when they’re on away games, we’re going to be lit up as if you now are in Chicago or Yankee Stadium or whatever it is showcasing those things. So this goes beyond the time that you’re open as a museum. It becomes now a true destination center. So we’re having a lot of fun with this. It’s going to have a lot of things that people haven’t seen before. We are tokenizing the entire project. This is going to be a lot of fun to watch. How the value of digital real estate over time. Will be worth more than the actual physical real estate itself. That’s my goal, is to prove out that type of world. And, you know, actually, for all your listeners out there, this is like the greatest time to ever be involved with technology and its interface with the built environment, because the cyber physical relationship is something like we’ve never seen before. And I think we’re just starting to, you know, just take the tippy toe of our toes out there and, and starting to feel the water, because now all of a sudden this becomes a very, very big deal because there’s practicality behind it. There’s real money behind it and the experiences. Well, all I can say is that I’m really happy that we’re going to be able to at least provide one tenth of what’s going to really, really happen is more people get involved in their ideas, then become part of this entire process.
Ashley Crowder:
No, it’s the opportunity is huge. As you said, we’re really just touching the iceberg. And there’s so much real value, not just as we’ve talked about reducing costs, reducing rework, increasing your speed to to market and going live and getting revenue beforehand. So, you know, what is your advice for, you know, geeks or architects out there of, you know, how do they get started? Where where would you begin if you’re trying to digitally innovate within your organization?
Paul Doherty:
I would absolutely start small, get quick wins, and scale quickly. I love the term. Uh, you know, just go fast and break things. You learn more from the mistakes. I’ve had spectacular failures in my career, and I’ve always learned more than than having a really good, successful piece. Right. Um, the successful piece almost feels like what I miss, right? Um, I think that there is we are very risk averse inside of the built environment, specifically in the architectural engineering construction space. Um, but what I’m finding. Is that the human resource issues that we’re having worldwide, for people coming into our professions and our trades and that type of thing is real. I think that I’m starting to see the younger generation really starting to flex because they’re saying, well, wait a second, you’ve been doing it this way, let’s do it that way. And when I start to see things like machine learning, large language models, things that people call AI. Mhm. I’m seeing that AI is going to make us more human because it’s taking care of the mundane. Now, there’s still a lot of hallucinations out there. It’s still not 100%, but it’s learning right. Which means that we’re going to attract a younger generation going there using what? That’s cool. Robotics being another one. You know, the big announcement for Neom over the weekend of, you know, the the $100 million that are being put into robotics. We’re starting to see the change happen with real time projects. If I were a sole practitioner or a, you know, a plumber with a Ford F-150, don’t be afraid of the simple things because they will make a difference. Things like copilot for your office. Start the process. Because guess what? Your competition may be already there. And the bottom line is, if I can take care of my HR, my my accounts payable, you know, my banking, uh, you know, all those things you don’t have to worry about, you know, spot the robot dog coming out and taking your job on the job site because you’re able to take care of the mundane. You can focus on more human things. And that’s what I mean about AI making us more human. We can have different types of conversations because I’m not worrying about the back office, the automation of those things, especially when it starts to come to everyday things like the way the Tesla’s going where they’re driving is improving, like compounding daily on the safety factors and making it work. Of course, we heard a lot of stories about, you know, accidents, everything else. But again, spectacular failures. That’s how you learn. So yeah, the best advice is wade into it and start to see how it affects you. I think that there are two many technology companies, especially in the design tech and the context or construction technology space, even the property tech space that think that AI and this tool isn’t this great. And it’s like, yeah, but has the market asked for it? Not that you have to ask the market for everything because, you know, uh, Henry Ford was famous for saying if I asked the market what they wanted, I would have added two more horses, right? Yeah. Like, sometimes you do have to go out there, but. What I like to see people do, especially with the service providers out there, the sulfur, you know, manufacturers, all these startups out there start to take a look at what people really do right and fit into their workflow. Get in there. Which is why platforms, I think, have seen their day, because there is no one tool that fits all. But what I am seeing are these discrete, functional tools that are doing remarkable things with at that point in the process. But if you follow the data, the data will be the thread that your responsibility by using just that little tool means that you’re the steward of that data for that moment in time. Once your contract is up in your paid, that data gets hand off to the next steward. That’s how the world works. That’s how construction works. It’s chaotic. It’s not like a manufacturing process. Getting back to that, where it’s more controlled inside four walls, it’s an outdoor factory that is in constant change. The idea that you have flexibility by following the data flow that lands itself in a product that can either do one of two things hand off the data to be more enhanced so that it mimics what’s in the built environment. Or I need a file or a document because of regulatory, a permit, whatever it is, it’s only at that moment in time that files and in documents need to be created. Otherwise keep it free. The world of data centric ecosystems is here, and we’re starting to see it at trade shows where they start to go up on like a panel and you can hand off from from a design piece of data into a sub trade, like a plumber that then gets handed off to a mechanical guy, and then all of a sudden it gets handed off to a facility management package. They showed this in London this past summer. I’m like, wow. You don’t need a monolithic cloud based construction cloud. Those days are over. The monolithic way of thinking is over. It’s about decentralization. Getting back to the world of of of blockchain and all that stuff. And the more decentralized you are, the healthier you’re going to be, and the project will be more successful.
Ashley Crowder:
Awesome. Yeah, I completely agree. Well, Paul, thank you so much for joining. I mean, you’re your wealth of knowledge over the years of how 3D is has transformed and continuing to transform the built environment is is amazing. So where can people find you if they want more?
Paul Doherty:
Um, any airline usually road to be. That’s that’s the Shakespeare seat. But I’m Bob, right? Um, so. Yeah, I’m up. Uh, pretty prolific on on social media again. Just getting the word out. Um, I do have a bestseller. It’s called Unlocking the Metaverse, a best seller on on, uh, on Amazon, which has been fun, by the way. Authors make no money, so I’m not doing it to make money. It’s about getting the word out. It’s about getting the word out. And because there are just it’s too noisy out there, especially with everyone crowing about this thing and that thing and crunching this and whatever. At the end of the day, um, it’s going to be the value of what you’ve left behind is what’s important. And I think that a lot of value that we don’t talk about in business, um, because it has a double edged sword to it. Um, I think we need to love each other better. And I’m not talking about the romantic MeToo type of love. I’m talking about the love of yourself, the love between the work in you and and just the love and spirit. Uh, I think that we need to embrace that more in business, and I just wish the listeners all the love in the world.
Ashley Crowder:
Awesome. Well, Paul, thank you so much. Really appreciate it. Thanks for
Paul Doherty:
joining. Thank you.